Culture Under Scrutiny

Why the FCA’s New Non-Financial Misconduct Rules Matter to Every Financial Services Firm

This article is drawn from Advice Matters, ZISHI’s quarterly publication for regulated professionals. The October 2026 edition also examines the evolving face of market abuse and the subtle signals of customer vulnerability under Consumer Duty.

Culture Under Scrutiny | Why the FCA’s New Non-Financial Misconduct (NFM) Rules Matter to Every Financial Services Firm

Workplace culture has become one of the defining governance issues facing financial services firms. Regulators increasingly recognise that behaviours such as bullying, harassment and violence are not simply employment matters, they can expose weaknesses in leadership, decision-making and organisational culture that ultimately affect customer outcomes and confidence in financial services.

On 1 September 2026, new Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) rules and guidance on Non-Financial Misconduct (NFM) came into force, extending the scope of the Conduct Rules for non-banking firms in relation to certain serious work-related misconduct and providing greater clarity on how misconduct should be considered when assessing an individual’s Fitness and Propriety.

The implementation date may have passed, but for firms the more important challenge has only begun.

The question is no longer whether policies and procedures have been updated. It is whether the new framework is working in practice:

  • Do managers recognise when workplace behaviour becomes a regulatory concern?
  • Can HR and Compliance distinguish an employment matter from a potential Conduct Rule breach?
  • Are Fitness and Propriety decisions consistent and evidence-based?
  • And, perhaps most importantly, are commercially valuable individuals held to the same behavioural standards as everyone else?

The changes represent more than a regulatory requirement. They reflect an important development in supervisory thinking. Culture is not simply an HR issue. It is a conduct, governance and leadership responsibility.

How organisations respond when standards are tested may say more about their culture than the misconduct itself.

When financial services professionals think about misconduct, attention usually turns to customer harm, financial crime, market abuse or breaches of regulatory requirements.

The FCA is increasingly asking firms to look inward:

  • How do people behave when commercial pressure rises?
  • Can junior employees challenge senior colleagues safely?
  • Are influential revenue producers held to the same standards as everyone else?
  • What happens when inappropriate behaviour is committed by someone considered indispensable to the business?

The risk does not begin only when misconduct occurs. It also arises from what managers overlook, what colleagues are afraid to challenge and what leaders choose to tolerate.

The behaviours that shape workplace culture also shape decision-making, accountability and the confidence employees have to raise concerns. A culture that discourages challenge can allow poor conduct, weak governance and customer risks to develop long before they become regulatory issues.

This article explores what the FCA’s changes mean in practice and, more importantly, why they should matter to every Senior Manager, HR professional, Compliance Officer and front-line leader. Through practical scenarios, it examines how culture, governance and accountability have become central components of conduct risk and why firms that continue to view Non-Financial Misconduct solely as an HR issue may overlook one of the most significant regulatory and commercial risks facing the industry.


1. The Leadership Test: When Performance and Behaviour Conflict

Most firms have policies prohibiting bullying, harassment and discrimination. Applying those policies becomes harder when the individual involved is commercially important. Consider a senior adviser who manages major client relationships and consistently exceeds revenue targets.

    Within the team, however, junior employees describe aggressive messages, public humiliation and threats concerning their careers. Several colleagues have resigned. Concerns have been raised informally, but employees are reluctant to submit formal complaints.

    Senior management knows the adviser is “difficult”, but the behaviour is rationalised:

    • “They get results.”
    • “That is simply their management style.”
    • “Nobody has made a formal complaint.”

    The regulatory issue is not limited to the adviser’s conduct. It extends to the firm’s response.

    When leaders excuse behaviour because of revenue, status or influence, employees learn that commercial value provides protection. Policies may encourage speaking up, but the lived experience suggests that challenging powerful people carries personal risk.

    The consequences can extend beyond employee relations. Someone who is afraid to challenge an intimidating manager may also hesitate to question unsuitable advice, aggressive sales practices or weak controls. Culture rarely fails in isolated compartments.


    2. Where Non-Financial Misconduct Happens

    Misconduct does not always occur in a formal office or result in a written grievance. It may arise through social events, digital communications and informal workplace networks.

    The Industry Event

    A senior executive repeatedly makes unwanted sexual comments towards a junior colleague during an evening reception attached to a professional conference. The executive argues that the incident occurred outside working hours.

    However, the individuals attended because of their professional roles, colleagues were present and the power imbalance arose from their workplace relationship. The relevant question is not simply where or when the behaviour occurred, but whether there was a sufficient connection to work.

    From September 2026, the Conduct Rules for non-banking firms will expressly cover certain bullying, harassment and violence towards colleagues where that work-related connection exists.

    The Private Messaging Group

    Employees maintain an unofficial WhatsApp group originally created to coordinate business travel. Over time, it becomes a forum for derogatory comments, sexually explicit jokes and the exclusion of particular colleagues.

    The fact that the group is not hosted on the firm’s systems does not automatically make the behaviour irrelevant. Its members are colleagues, its origins are work-related and its content may affect professional relationships and opportunities. Digital channels can expose a significant gap between a firm’s stated values and the culture employees experience.

    The Performance Meeting

    A manager provides direct criticism about an employee’s work. The discussion is uncomfortable but evidence-based, proportionate and professionally delivered. This should not automatically be treated as bullying.

    The FCA’s framework does not prevent managers from managing performance or making difficult decisions. Firms must distinguish legitimate authority from intimidation, humiliation or the misuse of power.

    A regime that treats every disagreement as misconduct would weaken effective management. Equally, describing repeated abusive conduct as “robust performance management” should not provide protection from scrutiny.


    3. When Private Conduct Becomes Relevant

    The FCA is not asking firms to monitor employees’ private lives or investigate every rumour, social media post or unpopular opinion.

    However, serious behaviour outside work may be relevant where it raises legitimate concerns about honesty, integrity, reputation or the risk an individual presents in a regulated role.

    The Weekend Incident

    A Certified Person is convicted of a serious violent offence following an incident unrelated to work.

    The firm should not assume either that the conviction automatically makes the individual unfit or that private conduct is automatically irrelevant.

    It should conduct a proportionate assessment, considering the seriousness and circumstances of the offence, its relevance to the role, the passage of time and evidence of rehabilitation.

    The key question is whether the conduct reveals qualities incompatible with the trust and responsibility associated with the position.

    This requires judgement rather than a mechanical rule.


    4. Where Firms Are Most Exposed

    Every firm should ask:

    • Where could power, commercial dependency or weak escalation allow misconduct to continue unchecked?

    Commercially Important Individuals

    Revenue producers, founders and senior relationship holders may accumulate influence beyond their formal authority.

    The risk is not that high performers are inherently more likely to commit misconduct. It is that firms may be less willing to challenge them.

    Warning signs include:

    • Repeated informal concerns.
    • High turnover within one team.
    • Complaints described as personality clashes.
    • Employees being moved instead of the behaviour being addressed.
    • Senior leaders intervening to protect a commercially important individual.

    A useful test is:

    Would the firm respond differently if the person generated no revenue?

    • If the answer is yes, the firm may have a governance problem.

    Line Managers

    Line managers shape daily culture. They allocate work, assess performance and frequently act as the first point of escalation.

    They must understand when to record, challenge, escalate or seek support. A manager who deliberately suppresses a credible complaint presents a different risk from one who was genuinely unaware of the behaviour.

    Small and Founder-Led Firms

    In smaller firms, personal relationships and short reporting lines can complicate escalation. A policy requiring concerns to be reported to a direct manager is ineffective where that manager is the subject of the concern.

    Employees require a genuinely independent route for raising issues.

    Hybrid Working

    Remote working can make exclusion, intimidation and inappropriate communication less visible.

    A manager may behave professionally in formal meetings while sending aggressive private messages afterwards. Culture exists wherever work takes place, not only where senior leaders can observe it.


    5. When HR Becomes a Regulatory Issue

    HR and regulatory assessments serve different purposes.

    An HR investigation may determine whether an employee breached internal policy.

    A regulatory assessment may consider whether the same facts:

    • Amount to a Conduct Rule breach.
    • Affect Fitness and Propriety.
    • Require FCA notification.
    • Should appear in a regulatory reference.

    A breach of internal policy does not automatically establish a regulatory breach. Equally, the absence of a formal grievance does not necessarily make credible evidence irrelevant.

    Firms therefore need a joined-up framework involving HR, Compliance, Legal and business leadership.

    The quality of the regulatory decision will depend heavily on the quality of the investigation. Unclear findings, inconsistent terminology and poor documentation make fair and defensible decisions significantly harder.


    6. The Senior Manager Challenge

    Senior Managers are not expected to guarantee that misconduct never occurs. They should, however, be able to demonstrate that effective systems exist to identify, assess and respond to it.

    Evidence of reasonable steps may include:

    • Clear allocation of responsibilities.
    • Independent escalation routes.
    • Effective management information.
    • Timely investigation of credible concerns.
    • Consistent decision-making criteria.
    • Appropriate involvement of HR, Compliance and Legal.
    • Challenge where commercial considerations influence outcomes.
    • Follow-up actions after cases are concluded.

    One of the greatest risks is that cultural warning signs remain separated across organisational silos.

    HR sees employee turnover. Compliance sees no customer complaints.

    The business continues to meet its targets. Senior leadership receives statistics but no coherent narrative.

    No one connects the pattern.


    7. The New Regulatory Reality: What Firms should have in place

    With the new framework now in force, attention shifts from implementation to effectiveness.

      Policies may have been amended and training completed, but those actions alone will not demonstrate a healthy conduct framework. Firms should now be asking whether their arrangements work when confronted with a difficult real-world case.

      That means being able to demonstrate:

      • Clear links between HR investigations and regulatory assessments.
      • Consistent Conduct Rule decision-making.
      • Robust Fitness and Propriety assessments.
      • Appropriate regulatory reporting and reference processes.
      • Independent routes for escalating concerns.
      • Management information capable of identifying patterns of behaviour.
      • Managers who understand when an issue requires escalation.
      • Evidence that commercial importance does not influence behavioural standards.

      Summary

      The FCA’s Non-Financial Misconduct framework reinforces that culture, conduct and accountability are closely connected. Firms must demonstrate not only that appropriate policies exist, but that managers can recognise, escalate and respond to concerns consistently.

      Ultimately, the real test of culture is how an organisation responds when its values, leadership and commercial priorities are tested.

      You need to login first to add to Favourites

      My Account