Speculation – Good or Bad?

Trading Strategy Playbook | Lesson 3

Speculators and speculation have a bad name – but is it justified?  While it is true that the markets originally evolved in response to the needs of trade – facilitating business and hedging commercial risk – it is equally obvious that modern financial markets are often dominated by speculative players.

The key relationship for any professional speculator is that between risk and reward, between the upside and downside, profit and loss.  So let’s take a speculator’s view of speculation – the pros versus the cons.

The principal – and arguably only – benefit of speculation is the provision of liquidity – the lifeblood of any market.  The majority of markets simply couldn’t and wouldn’t exist without the liquidity provided by the specs.

The criticisms of speculators and speculation are various but tend towards the emotional rather than the rational.  It’s true that speculators take money out of the markets – it is after all the very reason for their participation.  It’s also true that specs can cause volatility – speculative money is often characterised as “fast” in that positions can change significantly in the blink of an eye.  And speculation can cause problems in the real world – exaggerating spikes in commodity and energy prices, pressurising struggling companies, forcing governments to defend currencies.

But it’s also important to remember that markets allow participants to transfer risk, to protect themselves (and hopefully their customers) against price uncertainty.  And – as previously stated – most markets can only function effectively with the participation of the speculative community.

So the choice is clear – to either accept speculation as a necessary evil – or to take away the possibility of effective hedging.  It’s all too easy to blame speculators for all the ills of the markets but the truth – as ever – is more nuanced.

Author: Bill Beagles, Head of Training, Professional Trader Qualifications & Development, ZISHI

At ZISHI, we help you develop the skills and mindset needed to navigate today’s markets with confidence. Our tailored training solutions, real-time simulations, and expert-led programmes provide traders at all levels with the practical knowledge to succeed.  Explore a full portfolio of Financial Markets, Financial Products & Trading programmes here.

Interested in a career in financial trading or investment? ZISHI’s University-Accredited programmes, delivered with leading UK universities, offer immersive, hands-on training using real-time trading simulator platforms. Our Level 5 and Level 7 qualifications are industry-recognised and designed to mirror the demands of a graduate trading role. Gain practical skills and the confidence to succeed with our CISI recognised programmes.

Trading Strategy Playbook: Lessons from Trading Trainers

Over the next few weeks, we’ll be sharing key lessons from industry veterans to help traders at all levels sharpen their strategies, improve discipline, and master market dynamics.

Coming Next:

• • Lesson 4 | Futures v Options
    Learn why traders and hedgers often prefer options over futures—and how to use them to limit risk while staying open to market gains.

Here’s a look at the articles already featured in our Trading Strategy Playbook: Lessons from Trading Trainers series:

• • Lesson 1 | The 5 most common trading mistakes and how to avoid them
    Most traders fail by making common trading mistakes. Learn the top 5 to avoid—before you make them—with expert insights from ZISHI.

• • Lesson 2 | Trading Choices: Selecting the Right Market Instruments.
    Once upon a time, traders had limited options—now, from futures to CFDs and spread betting, the possibilities are endless. But which is right for you?

Don’t miss an update!

📩 Sign up for the full series straight to your inbox