Trading vs Investing: What’s the Difference and Which Is Better for You?

Trading Strategy Playbook | Lesson 5

Some crime novels are ‘howcatchems’ not ‘whodunnits.’ In a ‘whodunnit’ you solve the mystery in the final paragraph. In a ‘howcatchem’ you know the answer in the first, the mystery is ‘how and why.’ 

This is a ‘howcatchem.’ The answer to the trading v investing question is time.

There is no hard ‘rule’ on what time duration separates trading from investing, if you twisted my arm, the accepted market standard is 1 year.

What Trading and Investing Have in Common

Before we delve into the ‘how and why,’ let us start with what they have in common. Both are trying to make money by forecasting the change in price of an asset. Maximum return for minimum risk. Both operate in the same markets (shares, currencies, interest rates, bonds, commodities, crypto) and the exchanges do not distinguish investors from traders, they are all market participants.

Trading and investing are not substitutes for each other; it is not the vegan option versus steak on a menu. They are quite

That one key difference -time – between a trade and an investment does have enormous implication in terms of ownership, strategy, risk, time management, cost, and cortisol (stress hormone) level.

Ownership: Who Holds the Asset?

Let us further define both terms. Investing means buy it, own it, and hold it, known as long-only; to generate income or capital growth or both. You are putting money in. Its IN vest.

That could mean voting rights and dividend payments for stocks, and ownership of debt in the case of bonds. The owner has committed the full price of the asset upfront and if prices fall you cannot profit from the decline.

Trading is speculating without the ownership requirement, with a time from nanoseconds to months and unlike investors, traders may also benefit from price falls known as a ‘shorting,’ using instruments such as derivatives and CFDs.  A very crude definition of both is that they are contracts settled by paying or receiving the difference between the open and closing price of the contract, be it a buy and sell or vice versa. Hence traders are not long only, you can go short, and you do not own the asset, you own a contract. The value of the contract is based on the price of an asset.

Strategy: Different Approaches, Different Goals

Trading requires strategies broadly classified by time. Day trading you will not be surprised, is trading in less than 1 day, while ‘scalping’ minutes or hours, sometimes even seconds. ‘Swing’ trading focuses on momentum from days to weeks. ‘News​’ trading focuses on economic data, such as company earnings & government data releases, news that is unexpected will move prices, its impact can be in fractions of a second. ‘Position’ trading may be closer to investing in style with positions held up to one year.  Many markets now are dominated by High-Frequency Trading (HFT) – with time measured in milliseconds, microseconds and even microwave connections measured in nanoseconds (1 billionth of second).

Unlike traders, investors are not usually classified by time. They tend to be classified by investment style such as ‘growth’ (looking for stocks that will outperform the market) or ‘value’ (looking for asset prices perceived low to their true financial value). ‘Passive’ investing focuses on minimizing trading activity and research (so costs) often via ETFs; while ‘active’ investors, are well, more active in managing their investments.

Investors can also be classified based on the asset class: large, medium, or small cap equity investors focus on company size based on market capitalisation. There are real estate investors, bond investors, commodity investors, ETF investors. Even climate, sustainability, and energy investors. There are 1000s of alternatives and permutations of investment styles. Hopefully its clear, trading and investing require quite different strategies, and this has significant implications for risk.

Risk: Volatility, Losses and Protection

Most investors diversify their portfolio to reduce risk. Traders may hedge a position to reduce risk.  Same objective, different methods. You can eliminate risk via hedging, you cannot eliminate risk by diversifying. That is my theory, feel free to prove me wrong. Traders use hedging to protect against losses, while diversification is a strategy to smooth out returns by spreading risk across assets in a portfolio.

Trading involves higher risk due to short-term price volatility that often results in sudden and potentially significant losses. A responsible short-term trader will employ  a risk/reward ratio​ to make money and mitigate losses with strict corresponding take profit and stop loss exit prices.  Given HFTs can trade in nanoseconds, even tiny delays in trade execution in a volatile market can be extremely costly.

The shorter-term nature of trading also lends itself to leverage. This involves putting down a fraction of the monetary value of your trade (margin) to open your position, to cover potential losses. Leverage a.k.a. gearing, increases buying power and profit potential but equally should carry a health warning of increased risk, exposure to market volatility and an unwanted call for more margin to cover losses. It will magnify profits and losses; hence traders need to constantly manage their positions.

Investing, in contrast, has lower risk as it focuses on long-term growth so does not react to short-term volatility in prices.  It tends to be fully cash paid rather than using leverage facilities. Theoretically you may lose all that cash if the price falls to zero, but the maximum loss is known. Investments may not even have a specific exit price, think of your pension, exit depends on time not price.  Stop losses are less common in investing, an investor would wait for an asset price to become profitable again if the price falls provided there has been no change in view of the asset’s long term growth potential.

Since trading risk unlike investing requires constant active management, this too has time implications. Trading demands more of it.

Time Management: Active vs Passive Commitment

Given trading carries a higher risk than investing that means active management of trading positions and constant monitoring of relevant news.

Investors may place a couple of trades a year, others may be more active or if satisfied with their choices, may go years without making a trade. Rebalancing a portfolio or diversification may boost the trade count. The point is they trade less than traders and all the research and most effort is in asset selection prior to the trade. Investors tend to be less concerned with volatility and short-term adverse price moves. If the volatility leads to crashes or rallies, investors may choose to use the opportunity to buy an asset or sell an existing one but generally remain focused on their long-term strategy and goals.

Traders need to stay alert and disciplined, constantly monitor prices, positions, orders, and breaking news. This demands more time and resources than investing and higher trading volumes means higher costs.  Care needed here though, just because traders trade more does not mean it costs more. The costs are hugely different.

Costs: Fees, Spreads, and Long-Term Impacts

There is a wide range of how active traders are: position traders​​ may only execute a few trades every few months. HFTs may trade tens of thousands of times a day. Buying and selling costs money (commissions) and ‘spreads’ (the difference between buy and sell prices). In volatile or illiquid markets spreads are likely to widen, further increasing costs. For HFTs even a small spread can quickly erode profits.

Investors pay an annual management fee and fund expenses and may face commission charges to the broker.  If you are investing in a mutual fund with 6% growth per annum and pay 2% a year in management fees and expenses, this will reduce growth given the long-term nature of investments. Making 4% not 6% annually compounded over a 20-to-25-year investment can be a huge opportunity loss.

There may well be tax implications too particularly in relation to whether the asset is owned or not owned and how it is purchased. Tax is way beyond the scope of this article.

Conclusion: Which Path Is Right for You?

There are other differences that fall in the ‘tend to’ rather than definitive category. Investors tend to analyse fundamentals (macroeconomic data, financial statements) while traders tend to focus on breaking news and technical analysis (price charts, candlesticks, and stochastics). Traders tend to accept more risk, a typical investor might by happy with a 5-10% annual return, but traders would be more likely to need that return per month and be able to cope with an equal loss. The more reward you need the more risk you have to take.  As a consequence, though I have no data, I would put ‘greater stress’ as a key difference between investing and trading. If there was a derivative contract for cortisol levels, I would be long for a trader and short for an investment manager. That is known as spread trading, but spreads are for another time.

FAQs: Trading vs Investing

Author: David Michael, Principal Trainer, ZISHI

At ZISHI, we help you develop the skills and mindset needed to navigate today’s markets with confidence. Our tailored training solutions, real-time simulations, and expert-led programmes provide traders at all levels with the practical knowledge to succeed.  Explore a full portfolio of Financial Markets, Financial Products & Trading programmes here.

Interested in a career in financial trading or investment? ZISHI’s University-Accredited programmes, delivered with leading UK universities, offer immersive, hands-on training using real-time trading simulator platforms. Our Level 5 and Level 7 qualifications are industry-recognised and designed to mirror the demands of a graduate trading role. Gain practical skills and the confidence to succeed with our CISI recognised programmes.

Trading Strategy Playbook: Lessons from Trading Trainers

Throughout this series, we have shared key lessons from industry veterans designed to help traders at all levels sharpen their strategies, improve discipline, and master market dynamics.

Here’s a look at the articles already featured in our Trading Strategy Playbook: Lessons from Trading Trainers series:

• • Lesson 1 | The 5 most common trading mistakes and how to avoid them
    Most traders fail by making common trading mistakes. Learn the top 5 to avoid—before you make them—with expert insights from ZISHI.

• • Lesson 2 | Trading Choices: Selecting the Right Market Instruments.
    Once upon a time, traders had limited options—now, from futures to CFDs and spread betting, the possibilities are endless. But which is right for you?

• • Lesson 3 | Speculation—Good or Bad?
    Is it fuelling market liquidity or creating unnecessary volatility? We break down the pros and cons.

• • Lesson 4 | Futures v Options
    Learn why traders and hedgers often prefer options over futures—and how to use them to limit risk while staying open to market gains.

Don’t miss an update!

📩 Sign up for the full series straight to your inbox